kpopfam.com site logo.






facebook logo with F6F2Ec as background color
Follow KpopFam FB page

EPIC21 — Learn Korean with original songs. Every music video comes with a free textbook in 20 languages, covering lyrics, pronunciation, vocabulary and grammar for TOPIK I & II. No sign-up, no payment.
It opens a new tab


Korea to Survey Underage K-pop Idols After NewJeans Report

South Korea Will Survey Underage K-pop Idols: What the Law Says and What Happens Next


South Korea’s culture ministry said Monday it will carry out its first comprehensive survey of underage entertainers in 2027 and review the government’s standard contracts for performers.

The announcement follows renewed concern over young K-pop singers’ rights, sparked by a New York Times report on NewJeans’ exclusive contracts.

The survey is still months from starting, and the ministry hasn’t finalized its scope. But the announcement puts a spotlight on a question the K-pop industry has long handled behind closed doors: what protections do teenage and pre-teen performers have, and who checks that those protections are real?

What the ministry announced

The Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism said it takes the concerns seriously. It plans to examine whether current rules adequately protect underage performers’ rights to education, rest and sleep.

The survey will try to establish how many underage artists are represented by agencies, how old they are and whether their basic rights are respected. The ministry has not yet settled on its scope or methodology.

South Korean officials hold a press conference announcing the 2027 underage K-pop idol survey and contract review after the NewJeans report.

Image used for informational, editorial, and commentary purposes only. Persons depicted are fictional illustrations.

A ministry official also said the government will expand psychological counseling and legal advisory services, and will review whether the standard contracts need improvements. Those standard contracts were first introduced in 2009 and have been revised since, with additional agreements added to strengthen protections for minors.

Follow @aeronedits18 –

The report that set it off

On Nov. 5, The New York Times published an investigation into exclusive contracts that NewJeans and its agency Ador, a Hybe subsidiary, signed in 2022. All five members were minors, aged 14 to 17.

According to Korea Herald’s summary, the report raised concerns about provisions requiring members to bear a substantial portion of expenses incurred during their trainee years, including cosmetic surgery and dermatological treatments.

It also questioned clauses that let the agency keep using the members’ names, likenesses and voices after their contracts ended, including for AI-generated content.

Other provisions drew scrutiny for broadly restricting personal conduct, including attitudes toward work and romantic relationships.

Two comparisons to the government’s template have drawn attention. According to the Kyunghyang Shinmun, the standard contract ends an agency’s rights over a performer’s name, likeness and voice when the contract ends, while the NewJeans contract allowed Ador to keep using or licensing them to third parties after its 2029 expiry.

The standard contract also calculates early-termination penalties by multiplying average monthly revenue by the remaining term, whereas the NewJeans contract reflected only months with actual revenue, which the Times said could inflate the figure.

The report was not entirely one-sided. It noted that Hybe covered the actual expenses of the members’ trainee period, so they could earn immediately after debut without debt

Follow @aeronedits18 + 100 %

What Hybe and Ador say

Hybe and Ador defended the contracts on Nov. 6. Hybe said all its labels sign the government-standard supplementary agreement for minors with their trainees, and denied that the contracts allow unauthorized use of the members’ voices and likenesses, including AI-generated content, saying individual consent is required.

Hybe also told the Times that the government’s standard contract is a nonbinding guideline. The companies also pointed to how the deals were made.

Hybe said the contracts were finalized after about three months of revisions involving then-Ador CEO Min Hee-jin, the members, their parents and some legal representatives. Min’s side disputes that account. Her representatives say Hybe’s legal team led the drafting, and that Ador had no independent legal department at the time.

The industry pushed back too. The Korea Popmusic Industry Association called the report a one-sided and biased assessment that overlooked Korea’s legal safeguards for artist contracts.

It’s worth being clear about what the report does and doesn’t establish. As allkpop noted, the Times investigation does not establish that the contracts were illegal, nor does it overturn the existing court ruling. A Seoul court ruled in 2025 that the contracts were valid.

What the law actually says

The main legal framework for young performers is the Popular Culture and Arts Industry Development Act. The article numbers below follow the English translation published by the Korea Legislation Research Institute (KLRI).

Who counts as a youth.
Article 2 defines a “youth” as a person under 19, excluding anyone for whom January 1 of the year they turn 19 has arrived.

Working hours.
Under Article 22, performers under 15 may provide services for no more than 35 hours a week and may not work between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m.
The one exception is the night before a school holiday, when work may continue until midnight with the performer’s and a guardian’s consent.
Under Article 23, performers 15 and older are limited to 40 hours a week, extendable by agreement by up to one hour a day and six hours a week. Night work is allowed if both the performer and a parent or guardian consent.

An important exception.
Both articles provide that the weekly limit does not apply where there are just grounds, such as overseas activities or long-distance travel.
In those cases the business must still guarantee the performer’s rights to education, rest and sleep. For a genre built on world tours, that carve-out matters.

Contract protections.
Article 21 requires a contract with a youth performer to include measures guaranteeing basic rights, including physical and mental health, education, publicity, sleep, rest and free choice.
It also bars compelling youth performers to perform excessive bodily exposure or immodestly erotic expressions.

The standard contract.
Article 8 directs the culture minister to prepare a standard form contract after consulting the Fair Trade Commission. The minister may give preference in financial support to businesses that use it.
That is an incentive for agencies, not a requirement. It helps explain why Hybe can describe the template as a guideline while the government treats it as a benchmark.

Oversight.
Under Article 24, the minister may recommend corrective measures where a youth performer’s contract is markedly unfavorable, and may issue a corrective order if the recommendation is ignored without just grounds.
Ignoring an order can bring an administrative fine of up to 10 million won under Article 41.
Article 18 also requires the minister to periodically research actual conditions in the industry, and allows the ministry to request data from businesses. That is the legal basis for a survey like the one now planned.

Where critics see gaps

One tension sits inside the law itself. Korea’s Labor Standards Act prohibits employing children under 15, yet the pop culture law lets performers under 15 work up to 35 hours a week, according to Bizhankook.

The Labor Standards Act sets 15 as the minimum employment age, with narrow exceptions for 13- to 15-year-olds through a labor ministry work permit.

The pop culture law says the Labor Standards Act applies in preference where artists are protected by it. Many performers, however, sign contracts as independent artists, not employees, which is a reason their situation is governed mainly by the entertainment law.

The Korea Times has also flagged two weaknesses. It reports that the law limits minors’ working hours and night work, but does not cover pre-debut training, and provides no direct penalty specifically for breaching those limits.

The English translation of the Act lists fines for several other violations, but none tied specifically to the hour limits in Articles 22 and 23.

The Korea Times adds that a 2025 amendment added protections and oversight requirements, including a youth protection officer to manage working hours and review contracts, though critics say implementation remains uneven.

Because the KLRI translation may not reflect the latest amendments, the Korean-language text on the government’s law portal is the final authority.

Why very young debuts sharpen the question

The ministry’s timing coincides with a debut that has pushed age back into public debate.

All nine members of A2O Lite, the girl group launched by former SM Entertainment chief Lee Soo-man, are minors, and three are 13.

The youngest members of its sister group A2O Soul are 14. Thirteen of A2O Soul’s 15 members are minors, and A2O Lite’s debut single topped Melon’s Top 100.

Underage K-pop idol trainee sitting on a dance studio floor filling out a South Korea survey with other trainees in the background.

Image used for informational, editorial, and commentary purposes only. Persons depicted are fictional illustrations.

Lee has acknowledged that many people are worried about the members’ ages.

Nothing in the sources suggests A2O has broken any rule. The point is scale: the issue has gained urgency as agencies debut idols at younger ages. A survey that counts how many underage artists work under agency contracts, and how they are treated, would for the first time give regulators data of their own.

A coffee helps support more articles like this

What to watch next

The survey’s design.
The ministry hasn’t finalized its scope. What counts as an underage entertainer, and whether trainees are included, will decide how useful the findings are.

The standard contract review.
Changes to the template could address the issues raised in the NewJeans case, such as post-contract use of voices and likenesses and the penalty formula.

The Fair Trade Commission.
The commission has opened an investigation into Hybe and Ador over their treatment of NewJeans member Danielle, and the complaint targets a penalty clause used across K-pop. An investigation is not a finding of wrongdoing.

Related legal proceedings.
Police referred Ador’s former CEO Min Hee-jin to prosecutors on Monday on suspicion of breach of trust over her alleged involvement in NewJeans’ attempt to terminate its contract. She denies the allegation.

The survey is scheduled for 2027, so concrete changes are some way off. For now, the announcement shows that a dispute over one group’s contracts has become a broader question for the industry: how young is too young, and who is checking?



Discover more from KPopfam.com

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.