The Other Side of K-pop Collecting: Album Waste, Secondhand Markets and the Rise of Sustainable Fandom
For K-pop fans, collecting is often part of the experience. A new comeback can mean a new album, another photobook, a different version to add to the shelf, or merchandise that brings fans closer to the artists they support. Collections grow over time, sometimes becoming personal records of years spent following a group.
But what happens when the excitement moves on?
An album that once felt essential can end up unopened in a drawer. A lightstick may no longer be used after a fan stops attending concerts. Photocards, posters and other merchandise can accumulate until there is simply no more room for them.
For some fans, the answer has traditionally been to sell, store or give away those items. Increasingly, however, fans and community organizations are finding more creative ways to keep unwanted merchandise in circulation.
Recent initiatives in Seoul and Jakarta offer a glimpse of this changing side of K-pop collecting. From shops giving away surplus albums to fan-led merchandise exchanges, a different conversation is emerging: collecting does not have to end when one person is ready to let go.
Seoul’s free album shelves reveal a hidden side of collecting
In October 2026, The Korea Herald reported on a merchandise shop in Myeong-dong, Seoul, where boxes of K-pop albums were being offered to visitors free of charge.
The selection included releases from recognizable groups such as NCT and IVE, alongside albums from other artists. Some came with photobooks, giving visitors an opportunity to take home physical merchandise without paying for it. The shop was among a growing number of Seoul stores offering free secondhand albums
The story behind these free albums is more complicated than a simple giveaway.
According to the shop owner, some customers purchase albums primarily for the photocards and other exclusive inclusions. Once those items have been removed, the remaining albums can be left behind. Some overseas buyers even ask retailers to ship only the collectibles, leaving the CDs and other contents behind.
In South Korea, multiple album purchases can also be connected to fan-signing sessions, video calls and other promotional events. For lottery-based events, purchasing more copies can mean receiving more entries, encouraging some fans to buy far more albums than they actually need.
The Myeong-dong shop owner explained that albums left behind by customers were generally stored until record labels authorized their disposal. Rather than simply throwing away the copies that had been cleared for disposal, he began offering them to international visitors for free.
For fans who cannot easily afford multiple albums, this creates an unexpected opportunity. A visitor might discover an album from a group they follow, pick up a release they missed, or bring home a souvenir for a friend.
It also gives an existing product another purpose.
An album that has already served its original buyer can still have value to someone else. The music, artwork, photobook and physical design do not necessarily lose their appeal just because the first owner has removed the collectible they wanted.
When one fan’s unwanted collection becomes another fan’s treasure
The same idea appeared in a different form in Jakarta, Indonesia.
On October 31 and November 1, 2026, KPOP4PLANET organized an offline K-pop merchandise exchange as part of the BersalingSilang event at Taman Ismail Marzuki. The initiative brought fans together to exchange or donate merchandise they no longer wanted to keep.
According to KPOPPOST’s report on the event, more than 200 people visited the KPOP4PLANET booth over the two days, and dozens of items changed hands. Fans brought albums, lightsticks, photo sets and season’s greetings packages. Some donated their merchandise so that other fans could take it home.
The reasons for participating were varied.
Some fans had stopped collecting and did not know what to do with their remaining merchandise. Others wanted to make room for new interests or exchange items without spending money on another purchase. Some had accumulated duplicate albums after buying multiple copies to enter fan-signing event raffles.
The exchange created an opportunity for these items to find new owners rather than remain unused at home.
It also offered something beyond the merchandise itself: a place for fans from different fandoms to meet, talk and connect. Visitors included fans of groups such as NCT, BLACKPINK, EXO and ITZY.
For some attendees, the event even meant taking home their first K-pop album.
That detail captures the appeal of secondhand collecting. An item that has become surplus to one person’s needs can become a meaningful first purchase for someone else.
The event was not presented as a rejection of K-pop collecting. Instead, it showed that fans can continue enjoying physical merchandise while considering alternatives to buying everything brand new.
The environmental cost behind the merchandise
These initiatives are taking place against a wider debate about the environmental impact of K-pop’s physical merchandise industry.
Albums are not simply CDs in a case. Depending on the release, they can include photobooks, posters, postcards, stickers, plastic wrapping, packaging inserts and other components. Different versions of the same release can also mean more materials being produced and distributed.
The scale of the issue has attracted attention in South Korea.
A report published by The Korea Herald in October cited Environment Ministry data obtained by the Hankook Ilbo, stating that 13 local entertainment companies produced a combined 6,667 metric tons of plastic products, including CDs and packaging materials, between 2021 and 2024.
The concern is not limited to the materials used in one album. It is also about how the market encourages physical purchases.
Fans may want to collect different versions, obtain particular inclusions or participate in promotional events. When those incentives are connected to buying additional copies, the number of albums produced and purchased can grow beyond what individual fans actually intend to keep.
A September 2026 report by The Herald Business described unopened albums being left in boxes near Ewha Womans University Station in Seoul. The report discussed how bulk purchases linked to fan-signing entries and randomized inclusions can leave fans with copies they do not need. It also cited consumer research showing that collecting merchandise and entering events were common reasons for buying albums. The Herald Business
This creates an uncomfortable contradiction.
Physical albums remain meaningful to many fans. They offer artwork, design, tangible memories and a way to support artists. Yet some of the purchasing practices surrounding them can result in large quantities of merchandise being left unused.
The question, then, is not whether fans should stop collecting. It is whether the industry can make collecting less wasteful without taking away the parts of the experience that fans enjoy.
Secondhand collecting gives merchandise a longer life
The Seoul and Jakarta examples point toward a simple alternative: keeping existing merchandise in circulation.
A secondhand market can take several forms. Fans can sell items they no longer want, exchange duplicates with other collectors, donate albums to new fans, or organize community events where merchandise can be passed along.
Each option serves a slightly different purpose.
Selling allows collectors to recover some of the money they spent. Trading gives fans an opportunity to find items they are missing without purchasing another new product.
Donations can make collecting more accessible to people who may not have the budget for brand-new releases.
Recommended Partner Offer
Check out featured promotions and partner deals curated for our readers.
View Partner Offer External Sponsor • Opens in New WindowCommunity exchanges add another dimension by turning the process into a social activity.
Importantly, this is not a new concept for collectors. Trading and reselling have long been part of K-pop fandom. What makes these recent examples interesting is the emphasis on the merchandise that might otherwise be forgotten, discarded or left unused.
The focus moves beyond the value of an individual collectible and toward the life of the entire collection.
A photobook can be passed to someone who appreciates the group’s visual concepts. An older album can introduce a new fan to a previous era. A lightstick can be used by someone attending their first concert. A set of season’s greetings can become a welcome addition to another collector’s shelf.
The original owner does not have to keep every item forever for it to remain meaningful.
Fans are also asking the industry to rethink how albums are sold
Reusing merchandise can help address what happens after a purchase, but it does not resolve every part of the problem.
KPOP4PLANET, a climate action platform created by K-pop fans, has been campaigning for changes to the industry’s album marketing practices through its Plastic Album Sins campaign.
The organization has highlighted three practices that it believes encourage repeated purchases: randomized photocards, excessive album versions and fan-signing raffles where the number of entries is tied to the number of albums purchased.
Its demands go beyond encouraging fans to recycle or exchange unwanted items. The campaign calls on major entertainment companies to stop marketing practices that encourage fans to buy the same album repeatedly, disclose information about album waste and greenhouse gas emissions, and develop plans to reduce their environmental impact. kpop4planet.com+1
This distinction matters.
Fans can make more thoughtful decisions about what they purchase, but they do not control every part of the system. Album formats, promotional incentives, packaging decisions and event-entry rules are largely determined by companies and retailers.
There have been efforts to introduce alternatives, including albums that provide access to music through QR codes or NFC technology rather than relying on a traditional CD. However, changing the format alone does not necessarily solve the issue if the same incentives for repeated purchases remain.
A more sustainable approach would need to consider both sides: how merchandise is produced and sold, and what happens to it after fans have finished using it.
Sustainable collecting does not mean giving up the hobby
There is an important difference between asking fans to stop collecting and asking the industry to make collecting more responsible.
For many people, K-pop merchandise is more than a product. It can represent a favourite comeback, a concert memory, a connection to a group or a friendship formed through fandom. Physical albums and collectibles have emotional value that cannot always be replaced by digital music or streaming.
That is why the most interesting part of the recent initiatives is their practical approach.
The free album shelves in Seoul do not tell fans that physical albums are meaningless. They recognize that an album can still bring enjoyment to someone else, even after its original buyer has taken what they wanted from it.
The Jakarta exchange makes a similar point. Fans were able to discover different merchandise, share their collections and connect with other people without necessarily purchasing new products.
These examples suggest that a collection does not have to be permanent to be valuable. Passing an item along can be another way of appreciating it.
There are also practical steps fans can take: exchanging duplicates, donating albums in good condition, selling items responsibly, organizing local swaps and thinking carefully before buying multiple versions of a release.
None of these actions alone will solve the industry’s larger environmental challenges. But they can help reduce the number of perfectly usable items that end up forgotten or discarded.
What comes after the unboxing?
K-pop’s collecting culture has become a major part of the global fandom experience. New releases, limited merchandise and collectible inclusions will continue to attract fans, and there is no reason to expect that enthusiasm to disappear.
But the life of merchandise should not end with the unboxing.
The developments in Seoul and Jakarta show that fans are beginning to explore what comes next. Some items can be given away. Others can be exchanged, donated or sold to someone who will appreciate them. A collection can change owners without losing the memories and enjoyment attached to it.
The next step will require more than individual fans making room on their shelves. Entertainment companies, retailers and event organizers also have a role to play in reducing unnecessary production and making responsible choices easier.
Ultimately, sustainable K-pop collecting is not about making fandom less exciting. It is about finding ways to keep the excitement alive while giving the things fans love a longer life.
Because sometimes the best next chapter for a K-pop album is not another shelf, another display case or another collector’s purchase.
Sometimes, it is simply finding its next fan.




